JFK vs LaGuardia — Which New York Airport Should You Choose?
JFK or LaGuardia? The honest answer depends on where you’re sleeping, what you’re flying, and how you’re getting into the city. Here’s the full comparison — distances, delays, and the transfer math for both.
Book Your Airport Transfer — JFK or LaGuardia
Prices are live and can move with demand — the fare in your search results is the exact total you pay, shown in full before you confirm.
Live prices, fixed rates — search, compare and book in under two minutes.
Choose Your Ride
The Short Answer
Choose LaGuardia if you’re staying in Manhattan or Queens on a domestic trip and want the shortest ride into the city. Choose JFK for international flights, most long-haul routes, better rail access (AirTrain + LIRR/subway), and trips to Brooklyn or Long Island. Flying in for a first NYC visit and staying near Times Square? Either works — LGA is closer, JFK is often cheaper to fly into and has the train. The detailed breakdown is below.
JFK vs LaGuardia at a Glance
Is JFK or LaGuardia Closer to Manhattan?
LaGuardia — by about half. LGA sits ~8 miles from Midtown; JFK is ~15–16 miles. In a car that’s roughly 25–45 minutes from LGA versus 45–75 from JFK. The one caveat: JFK has the train. On a Friday afternoon when the Van Wyck and the BQE are both crawling, AirTrain + LIRR from JFK (~35 minutes of train time to Penn Station) can beat a car from LaGuardia door-to-door. Going the other way? We run transfers between LGA and JFK too.
Is JFK or LaGuardia Closer to Times Square?
LaGuardia again (~9 miles vs ~16). If your hotel is in the Theater District and everything else is equal — price, schedule, airline — LGA is the simpler arrival. Our JFK to Times Square guide covers every option if you land at JFK.
Is JFK or LaGuardia Closer to Brooklyn?
JFK. Southern and eastern Brooklyn (Flatbush, Midwood, Sheepshead Bay, Coney Island) is JFK’s backyard, and even Downtown Brooklyn is marginally closer to JFK. For Williamsburg and Greenpoint in the north, LGA closes the gap. Staying in Brooklyn with heavy luggage? A fixed-fare car from JFK starts at $65 and skips two subway transfers.
JFK vs LaGuardia vs Newark — The Three-Way Choice
Newark (EWR) is the third option: best for New Jersey destinations and sometimes the cheapest flight, with its own AirTrain + NJ Transit rail link to Penn Station (~60–75 minutes from the terminal). The trade-off is distance — EWR to Manhattan crosses two rivers’ worth of traffic, and a car transfer runs $90+. Connecting between airports? We cover EWR ↔ JFK transfers as well. Rule of thumb: Manhattan + domestic → LGA; international + Brooklyn/Long Island → JFK; New Jersey → EWR.
Which Airport Is Better for Delays and Reliability?
Both sit in the most congested airspace in the US, and both suffer when summer thunderstorms roll in. JFK’s longer runways and international schedule give it more recovery options for long-haul; LGA’s shorter-haul network recovers faster after a ground stop but has less slack per flight. There’s no honest universal winner — check your specific flight’s on-time history, and whichever you pick, book a transfer with flight tracking (included with every booking here) so a delay never strands you at the curb.
Getting From Either Airport — Book Once, Ride Fixed-Fare
Set your airport and destination in the widget above for an instant fixed fare — the same price whether you land at JFK or LaGuardia, with flight tracking and free cancellation. No surge, no meter, no guessing.
JFK vs LaGuardia FAQs
Check Live Prices for Your Route
Exact fare for your trip, fixed at booking — no surge, no meter.
How Pickup Works
Why Ride With JFK Airport Shuttle
Whichever airport you pick — your driver can be waiting at arrivals.
Ready to Ride? Your Driver Is Waiting.
Fixed fares, flight tracking and free cancellation — book in under a minute.
More JFK Transfer Guides
Size & Scale: Which New York Airport Is Bigger?
By every measure, JFK is the biggest of the three. It covers about 4,930 acres in Jamaica, Queens, runs five operating terminals (1, 4, 5, 7 and 8 — with new terminal projects rising alongside), and handled roughly 63 million passengers in 2024, the most of any New York airport. Newark (EWR) is second: about 2,027 acres, three terminals, roughly 49 million passengers. LaGuardia (LGA) is by far the smallest — about 680 acres and roughly 34 million passengers — which is exactly why it feels quicker to get through. So if your search was "which airport is bigger, JFK or Newark": it is JFK, and it is not close. Bigger also cuts both ways — more airlines, more long-haul routes and more lounges at JFK, but longer walks and longer taxi queues too.
Where Are They? JFK, LaGuardia & Newark on the Map
Picture the map of New York and the three airports sit in three different corners. LaGuardia is in East Elmhurst, in northern Queens on Flushing Bay — about 9 miles from Midtown Manhattan, the closest of the three. JFK is in Jamaica, in south-east Queens on Jamaica Bay — about 15 miles from Midtown, south of LaGuardia. Newark is not in New York at all: it sits in Newark, New Jersey, about 16 miles west of Midtown across the Hudson River. That geography explains most of this page: LGA wins for Manhattan closeness, JFK wins for Queens/Brooklyn/Long Island access and international flights, and EWR wins if you are based on the New Jersey side. Whichever pin on the map you choose, we run fixed-fare car service and inter-airport transfers between all three.
More JFK vs LaGuardia vs Newark FAQs
Still deciding between airports?
Whichever one you land at: fixed fare, flight tracking, driver in arrivals.
Book Your Airport TransferReady to Book Your JFK Transfer?
Live prices, fixed at booking, tolls included — search your route now and your driver tracks your flight.

